Thanks for great opportunity
experiencing blog-workJ I like this task, because it not only gave me chance
to improve my knowledge in stylistics, but also I discovered a new writer, read
a wonderful story and developed some
skills in creation of my own blogJ
субота, 29 листопада 2014 р.
1850-1893
The passage under consideration is the short story “A Dead Woman's Secret” written by the French author of the naturalistic school Guy de Maupassant, who is generally considered the greatest French short story writer. Maupassant took the subjects for his pessimistic stories and novels chiefly from the behavior of the bourgeoisie, the Franco-Prussian War and the fashionable life of Paris. The writer is usually regarded as one of the fathers of the modern short story and one of the form's finest exponents, with some 300 short stories written. His first published story "Ball of Fat" (1880) is often considered to be his masterpiece. Maupassant wrote comfortably in both the high realistic and fantastic modes. The fantastic approach in the author’s style was influenced by his mental state as he was suffering from a disease that caused increasing mental disorder. It is reflected in his nightmarish stories, which have much in common with Edgar Allan Poe's supernatural visions. Maupassant’s most famous novel “Bel Ami” is hold in a high regard by critics and reading audience in general.
The
short story under consideration is devoted to a mother who just passed away and her
family members finding out “secrets” about
their deceased mother. She had died from a painless death in her bed looking like she had got herself ready
before dying. She laid there looking calm and
peaceful as her son and daughter were desperate about her death. Her children decided to read the letters their
mother had wrote which were kept in her drawer.
At first they enjoyed the letters and thought they should bury them with her until the daughter opened a letter
written by a man named ‘Henry’, who was not their father. The letter from this
man was a confession in love. When they finished reading the letter they got up and left their
deceased mother on her bed in the darkened room.
The
basic theme of the story is devoted to family and private relationships. The
extract describes a farewell of children with their mother, who has just passed
away, and the shift from despair and grief to disgust and hostility which is
produced by the dead mother’s revealed secret. The basic idea of the novel in
the most general sense is that everyone has secrets, no matter how descent,
rational and open-minded a person may seem to be. The other idea dwelled on in
the passage is a children’s ungratefulness. Even though, their mother dedicated
her entire life to their children and did everything for their sake (“She had, from childhood up,
armed them with a strict moral code, teaching them religion, without weakness,
and duty, without compromise. He, the man, had become a judge and handled the
law as a weapon with which he smote the weak ones without pity. She, the girl,
influenced by the virtue which had bathed her in this austere family, had
become the bride of the Church through her loathing for man.”), her children can’t accept the fact that she had a
secret lover. Moreover, the children knew that their mother was unhappy with
their father (“They had hardly known their father, knowing only that he
had made their mother most unhappy, without being told any other details.”) but even this fact can’t reinforce them to forgive
their mother. Other idea explored in the extract is that keeping a secret from
someone can change the entire perspective and attitude of a person, especially
if it concerns the closest people. The author’s message is to be sincere and
cordial in order to avoid misunderstanding, quarrels and consequently broken
hearts and destinies.
The
events in the analysed text happen in the dead woman’s room, where her body
rests quietly and peacefully in her bed. The setting of the events in the given
extract is realistic with a soft poetic touch and is described in a rather
general way. The peculiarities of the setting are conveyed by the author
implicitly through the characterization of the character’s emotions and
feeling. Judging from the very first passage of the story: “The woman had died without
pain, quietly, as a woman should whose life had been blameless. Now she was
resting in her bed, lying on her back, her eyes closed, her features calm, her
long white hair carefully arranged as though she had done it up ten minutes
before dying. The whole pale countenance of the dead woman was so collected, so
calm, so resigned that one could feel what a sweet soul had lived in that body,
what a quiet existence this old soul had led, how easy and pure the death of
this parent had been.” we may assume that the
setting is as quiet, plain and calm as the state of the dead woman. This
description reinforces the idea that a death is a natural and inevitable part
of each human being’s life.
Other
details of the setting given by the author, such as “The ticking of the clock, hidden
in the shadow, could be heard distinctly, and through the open window drifted
in the sweet smell of hay and of woods, together with the soft moonlight. No
other noise could be heard over the land except the occasional croaking of the
frog or the chirping of some belated insect. An infinite peace, a divine
melancholy, a silent serenity surrounded this dead woman, seemed to be breathed
out from her and to appease nature itself.” contribute to our understanding of
the atmosphere in the passage and convey the idea that death is not pain and
suffering but peace and calmness. A lot of expressive means are used by the
author to reinforce this idea, they are epithets: ‘soft moonlight’; ‘sweet smell’; metaphors ‘The ticking of the clock, hidden
in the shadow’; ‘a silent serenity surrounded this dead woman’; ‘…seemed
to be breathed out from her’; ‘the open window drifted in the sweet smell of hay and of woods’ and all the emotionally colored
expressions such as ‘divine melancholy’; ‘sweet smell’ etc. The description of the noise ‘No other noise could be heard
over the land except the occasional croaking of the
frog or the chirping of some belated insect’ proves that nothing else could
be heard because the room was surrounded by a complete silence and
quietness. These stylistic devices are
used to create a peaceful atmosphere and convey the symbol of death as a
natural part of life that release a soul from the burden imposed by mortal
life.
From
the point of view of presentation the text is the 3rd person narrative. There are four characters
we meet in the extract. They are the dead woman, her daughter Marguerite, known
as Sister Eulalie, her son and a priest. Other characters, who are mentioned,
are the dead woman’s husband Rene and her lover Henry.
The writer reveals the dead
woman’s personality by means of narrative
description with both implied and explicit judgments. From the author’s
characterizations we derive the impression of the dead woman as strong, loving
and caring personality. When the narrator informs us that she armed her
children with a strict moral code, teaching them religion, without weakness,
and duty, without compromise; we come to share
respect and approval of the dead woman’s doings. The facts that her son
had become a judge and handled the law as a weapon with which he smote the weak
ones without pity and that her daughter was greatly influenced by the virtue
which had bathed her in this austere family, had become the bride of the Church
through her loathing for man prove that the dead woman had brought up her
children in a decent way and instilled high moral values and qualities in them.
These comments of the narrator clearly indicate
that this woman devoted her entire life to her children.
The
author reveals some surface details of physical appearance of the dead woman,
for example:
·
…her eyes closed, her
features calm, her long white hair carefully arranged as though she had done it
up ten minutes before dying;
·
The whole pale countenance
of the dead woman…;
·
On the other side of the
long body the other hand seemed still to be holding the sheet in the death
grasp…
·
The nun was wildly-kissing
the dead woman's hand, an ivory hand as white as the large crucifix lying
across the bed.
All these details contribute to the calm atmosphere
and suggest the idea that the dead woman had quiet and wise nature. The very
first sentence of the story ‘The woman had died without pain, quietly, as a
woman should whose life had been blameless.’ contains the adjective
‘blameless’ which gives the author’s explicit judgment about the dead woman
life. Other direct characterization of her personality is driven from the
description of the dead woman’s body and the effect it produces: ‘The whole
pale countenance of the dead woman was so
collected, so calm, so resigned that one could feel what a
sweet soul had lived in that body, what a quiet existence this old soul had led, how
easy and pure the death of this parent had been.’ The writer
explicitly emphasizes the goodness of the character and her virtues which
conveyed through the description of her dead body and the expression of her
face.
The personalities of the
antagonists are described by the author mainly through the speech, actions and consciousness characterization. The personalities of
the dead woman’s children are conveyed through their attitude towards their
mother, who are desperate and miserable about her death at first and then feel
hostility towards her. The following extracts from the story illustrate the
shift in their attitudes:
·
Kneeling beside the bed, her son, a magistrate
with inflexible principles, and her daughter, Marguerite, known as Sister
Eulalie, were
weeping as though their hearts would break.
·
The nun was wildly-kissing the dead woman's hand, an ivory hand as white as the large crucifix lying
across the bed.
·
Grief and tears stopped her; she could not continue.
·
Then the judge, still kneeling, his head buried in the bed clothes, cried in a voice altered
by grief and deadened by the sheets and
blankets…
·
And his sister, frantically
striking her forehead against the woodwork, convulsed, twitching and trembling as in an epileptic
fit…
·
The crisis slowly calmed down and they began to weep quietly, just as on the sea when a
calm follows a squall.
·
And
they loved her as they never had loved
her before. They measured the depth
of their grief, and thus they discovered how lonely they would find themselves.
·
They
now became solitary, lonely beings;
they could no longer look back.
·
The
nun, straight as a statue, tears
trembling in the corners of her eyes, was watching her brother, waiting.
Then he crossed the room slowly, went to the window and stood there, gazing out into the dark night.
·
He
stepped forward, quickly picked up the letters and threw them pell-mell back into the drawer. Then he closed the
curtains of the bed…
·
… without looking again at the mother upon whom he had passed sentence,
severing the tie that united her to son and daughter…
This sequence of these events shows the shift in the children’s
attitudes towards their mother and displays their emotions which are changing
from despair to hostility and misunderstanding. From loving their mother as
they never had loved her before they become hostile and cold on discovering the
fact that their mother had kept on secret. Their stubbornness and unwillingness
to forgive their mother and accept her as she was with all her flaws and
drawbacks proves the fact that they are egoistic and ungrateful to the woman,
who scarified her life to them but was eager to keep something in secret.
Moreover, the children’s emotional state and the tragic emotions do not
correlate with the peaceful and quiet setting described by the author which
means that they are not ready to accept the fact that their mother is dead and
let her soul rest in peace. On the other, it is quite a natural reaction to the
death of the close person but what makes it unnatural is their hostile attitude
and stubbornness which serve as a characteristic feature of their
personalities.
Speech characterizations employed by the author as
well illustrate this gradation in attitude:
·
“Thank
you, "father, but my brother and I prefer to remain alone with her. This
is our last chance to see her, and we wish to be together, all three of us, as
we--we--used to be when we were small and our poor mo--mother----”.
·
“Mamma,
mamma, mamma!”.
·
“Jesus,
Jesus, mamma, Jesus!”.
·
“You
remember how mamma used always to read her old letters; they are all there in
that drawer. Let us, in turn, read them; let us live her whole life through
tonight beside her! It would be like a road to the cross, like making the
acquaintance of her mother, of our grandparents, whom we never knew, but whose
letters are there and of whom she so often spoke, do you remember?".
·
"These
ought to be put in the grave with her; they ought to be used as a shroud and
she ought to be buried in it.".
·
"Let us now retire, sister.".
The speech characterizations are marked by the usage
of exclamatory sentences that shows the emotional state of the children and aposiopesis in the
sentence ‘we wish to be
together, all three of us, as we--we--used to be when we were small and our
poor mo--mother----’ that show that the daughter was unable to complete the sentence due
to her grief and despair; repetitions “Mamma, mamma, mamma!” and “Jesus, Jesus, mamma, Jesus!” that serve to emphasize their
emotional state.
The last character introduced in the extract is a
priest, whose image is created through the
author’s explicit judgments, surface details of appearance and speech
characterizations. The author’s explicit judgments about the priest are marked
by the instances of irony and sarcasm such as: “He looked sad, with that assumed
sadness of the priest for whom death is a bread winner. He crossed himself
and approaching with his professional gesture…”;
“Once more serene, the priest bowed, thinking of his bed.”. The
surface details of his appearance and physical state are as well marked by the
author with the help of irony: “He
was red and out of breath from his interrupted digestion, for he had made
himself a strong mixture of coffee and brandy
in order to combat the fatigue of the last few nights and of the wake which was
beginning.” The priest’s actions are depicted with the help of syntactic expressive
means, such as asyndeton, which shows the mechanic nature of the procedure
which is performed by him so often that has already become a routine and a way
for earning a living: “He kneeled, crossed himself, prayed, arose
and went out quietly…”. The most powerful metaphor that is used by
the author to characterize the priest and that gives a reader a clear
understanding of the priest’s attitude towards death is “the priest for whom
death is a bread winner”.
The priest’s speech adds to the image
of a person, for whom death is a routine. His phrases like: “Well, my poor
children! I have come to help you pass these last sad hours.”; “As you wish, my children.”; “She was a saint!” show
his pretended concern and mocking solemnity.
The plot of the
story starts with the development of events, omitting such parts as
introduction and exposition. The events in the story run rather dynamic
displaying the changes which occur in the attitude of the children toward their
mother. The climax of the story can be indicated at the point, when the
children have read the letter from their mother’s lover, which produced a
dramatic effect on their attitude towards her. The climax occurs at this point
in the story: “There was none, but only
under the words, “The man who adores you,” the name “Henry.” Their father's
name was Rene.”. On this sharpest moment of the story the tension reaches
its highest point. After this point the tension slowly releases but the author
gives no definite answers. The author only implicitly gives some hits that can
be driven from the characters actions: “He
stepped forward, quickly picked up the letters and threw them pell-mell back into the drawer. Then he closed the curtains of the bed… the
son slowly left his armchair, and without
looking again at the mother upon whom he had passed sentence, severing the
tie that united her to son and daughter…” and words “Let us now retire, sister.”. On the basis of the character’s
actions that follow the climax of the story and that serve as an anticlimax to
it we may derive our own conclusions of the events.
In order to create the striking image
of the setting, to portray the characters, to reveal the idea, to render the
general mood of the passage the author resorts to the numerous stylistic
devices which help to achieve the listed goals.
Lexical expressive means are used by
the author to portray the setting and the characters and to create the
atmosphere in the passage. Among the most powerful lexical stylistic devices
are:
·
Metaphors: “they were
weeping as though their hearts would
break”; “She had, from childhood up, armed them with a strict moral code”; “death
is a bread winner.”; “An infinite
peace, a divine melancholy, a silent serenity surrounded this dead woman, seemed to be breathed out from her and
to appease nature itself.”; “those epistles which smell of another
century”; “Grief and tears stopped her” etc.
·
Epithets: “a
sweet soul”; “a divine melancholy”; “a silent serenity” etc.
·
Metonymy: “A few light taps on the door caused the two sobbing heads to look up” (Synecdoche).
·
Personification: “that one could feel what a sweet soul
had lived in that body, what a quiet existence this old soul had led”; “My
whole soul and body cries out for you, wants you.”.
·
Simile: “…an ivory hand as white as the large crucifix lying
across the bed.”; “The nun, straight as a statue…”.
·
Irony: “Once
more serene, the priest bowed, thinking of his bed.”; “He was red and out of
breath from his interrupted digestion, for he had made himself a strong mixture
of coffee and brandy in order to combat the fatigue of the last few nights and
of the wake which was beginning”.
There are some cases of the author’s usage of phonetic
expressive means, with serve to create the atmosphere of the setting of the
story:
·
Onomatopoeia: “No
other noise could be heard over the land except the occasional croaking of the frog or the chirping of some belated insect.”.
More numerous are the cases of syntactic stylistic
devices which are used by the author to indicate the emotional state of the
characters. The most widely used syntactic stylistic device is asyndeton: “Now she was resting in her
bed, lying on her back, her eyes closed, her features calm, her long white hair
carefully arranged.”; “He kneeled, crossed himself, prayed, arose and went out
quietly”; “Then he crossed the room slowly, went to the window and stood there,
gazing out into the dark night.”; “I feel your lips against mine, your eyes in
mine, your breast against mine.” etc. Other syntactic stylistic devices used by
the author are:
·
Aposiopesis: “Thank you,
"father, but my brother and I prefer to remain alone with her. This is our
last chance to see her, and we wish to be together, all three of us, as
we--we--used to be when we were small and our poor mo--mother----”; “I have
kept in my mouth the taste of your kisses--”.
·
Emphatic
sentences: “It was their
prop, their guide, their whole youth, all the best part of their lives
which was disappearing. It was their
bond with life, their mother, their mamma, the connecting link with their
forefathers which they would thenceforth miss.”.
·
Repetition:
“Mamma, mamma, mamma!”; “Jesus, Jesus, mamma, Jesus!”; “The whole pale
countenance of the dead woman was so collected, so calm, so resigned…”; “I love
you, I love you!”.
·
Antithesis: “And the memories,
those distant memories, yesterday so
dear, to-day so torturing, came to their minds with all the little
forgotten details, those little intimate familiar details which bring back to
life the one who has left.”.
·
Anticlimax:
“And both of them, shaken by a storm of grief, gasped and choked. The
crisis slowly calmed down and they began to weep quietly, just as on the sea
when a calm follows a squall.”.
The ideas expressed through the use
of stylistic devices are connected first of all with the emotional state of the
characters. The repetitions, emphatic sentences, anticlimax and aposiopesis
listed below are aimed at revealing the feelings of the children towards their
mother. With the use of both lexical and syntactic stylistic devices the author
vividly describes the shift in attitude of children towards their mother before
and after the revelation of the secret. The metaphors, epithets and
personification explain and clarify the main theme and idea of the story. The
use of repetitions and aposiopesis attracts the reader’s attention and shows
the state of mind of the characters, their grief and despair.
The story “A Dead Woman’s Secret” has inspired in me a
lot of feelings and thoughts connected with the human relationships, family,
love, trust and ignorance. The story is deeply philosophical and instructive.
From the first lines of the story the reader is introduced to a woman, whose
life was divine and blameless and her soul was sweet and her death was easy and
not painful. Then the author brilliantly depicts the tragedy which is caused by
her death. The woman’s children are experiencing real horror, despair and
grief. Their emotional state is described by the author with the help of
numerous stylistic expressive means to such an extent that we see a striking
image of two people who are miserable about the death of their mother. They
loved their mother like every child does and like every child they could never
have thought that their mother could have a hidden affair. But at the point
when they got to know the truth their attitude sharply changed as though their
mother had committed a crime and was no longer the person, who devoted her
entire life to her children. The dead women brought up her children in a decent
way and instilled high moral values and qualities in them but they were not
wise enough to forgive her. The most important notion that is explored in this story is the notion
of forgiveness. We should be more merciful, less superficial and shallow to our
close people. The other author’s message is to accept people as they are and to
love them for who they really are, without paying attention to their past,
drawbacks and negative traits. One more idea is the idea of gratefulness and
egoism which is opposed to it. Children should value their parents, be grateful
to them and accept the fact that their parents are not perfect. Finally, the
last idea is that one should always be sincere
and cordial in order to avoid misunderstanding and not to hurt close people.
Підписатися на:
Дописи (Atom)